Everything That’s Wrong With Roubini’s Central Bank Crypto Love Letter

Neutral Everything That’s Wrong With Roubini’s Central Bank Crypto Love Letter

Whenever Nouriel Roubini talks smack about Bitcoin, it's hard to know how to respond. Do you ignore "Dr. Doom," mindful of the mantra to not feed the trolls? Or do you tackle him head on, shooting down his fallacies, but granting the attention he so desperately craves? It's a conundrum, but in the case of the doc's provocative new piece, a paean to central bank coins, the only option is to shoot for the heart. Here's everything that's wrong with Roubini's latest brain dump. Also read: A Brief Introduction to Voluntaryism for Crypto Neophytes

Oops He Did It Again

Those of us who were raised in the internet trenches, on the sort of forums where trolls like to troll trolls, know that giving attention-whores the oxygen they crave is generally a bad idea. Sometimes, though, your bête noire comes out with something so asinine the only option is to take the bait. From the title alone - "Why Central Bank Digital Currencies Will Destroy Cryptocurrencies" - you can tell that the author of the hit piece is faded economist Nouriel Roubini. You can also tell that at the end of each sentence, the excitable Dr. Doom had to pause to wipe the spittle from his screen.

The career of the Stern School of Business lecturer has been on a downward trajectory ever since BTC was changing hands for 40 bucks. Having been wrong about cryptocurrency for six years straight, Roubini isn't going to change his tune now. Stubbornness is one of his many attributes. It's a shame, because if it were only possible to see past his Trumpian bluster, Roubini occasionally has some good points to make.

Our subject begins by acknowledging that we're transitioning to a cashless society and explaining that central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are on the horizon. Up until now, Roubini is on solid ground. Unfortunately, he then ruins it by going full Dr. Doom:

Starry-eyed crypto-fanatics have seized on policymakers' consideration of CBDCs as proof that even central banks need blockchain or crypto to enter the digital-currency game. This is nonsense. If anything, CBDCs would likely replace all private digital payment systems, regardless of whether they are connected to traditional bank accounts or cryptocurrencies.

Somebody Call a Doctor

As is often the case with Roubini's unhinged rants, there are grains of truth scattered in there, such as the observation that central banks won't use conventional blockchains to issue their digital currencies. That much can be safely assumed. But then our protagonist's argument starts to rapidly unfold with the assertion that "If a CBDC were to be issued, it would immediately displace cryptocurrencies, which are not scalable, cheap, secure, or actually decentralized."

It's hard to know where to start with this sentence, which is filled with more logical fallacies and doublethink than the notion that "XRP was gifted to Ripple." Apparently:

  • CBDCs will "immediately displace" cryptos - citation needed
  • Cryptos are "not cheap" - explanation needed
  • "Not secure" - citation needed
  • "Not actually decentralized" - and CBDCs are?

"Yes. Everyone will love using backdoored central bank digital currencies and no one would ever want to use anything else ever," read one sarcastic response to Dr. Doom's absurd suggestion.

If you can stomach more sensible chuckles, let's read on to where Roubini claims "Enthusiasts will argue that cryptocurrencies would remain attractive to those who wish to remain anonymous. But, like private bank deposits today, CBDC transactions could also be made anonymous, with access to account-holder information available, when necessary, only to law-enforcement authorities or regulators, as already happens with private banks."

Moving on from sensible chuckles to sides leaving orbit, Roubini continues: "By transferring payments from private to central banks, a CBDC-based system would be a boon for financial inclusion. Millions of unbanked people would have access to a near-free, efficient payment system through their cell phones." Cos, you know, the only thing preventing impoverished Somalis from accessing banking services is the lack of a central bank cryptocurrency. The global financial system totally wants to include the downtrodden; it was just waiting to invent a centralized cryptocurrency before inviting them to the party.

Bitcoin could drop to $50 and it would still be a better investment than any CBDC. Whatever happens to central bank digital currencies, they will never displace decentralized cryptocurrencies, just as Roubini will never displace the gnawing pain that tells him he should have bought bitcoin in 2013.

What are your thoughts on Nouriel Roubini's latest rant? Let us know in the comments section below. Images courtesy of Shutterstock. OP-ed disclaimer: This is an Op-ed article. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own. Bitcoin.com does not endorse nor support views, opinions or conclusions drawn in this post. Bitcoin.com is not responsible for or liable for any content, accuracy or quality within the Op-ed article. Readers should do their own due diligence before taking any actions related to the content. Bitcoin.com is not responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any information in this Op-ed article.

Kai's been playing with words for a living since 2009 and bought his first bitcoin at $19. It's long gone. He's previously written white papers for blockchain startups and is especially interested in P2P exchanges and DNMs.

11/20/2018 / 10:30:58 Source: bitcoin.com

BTC
1 BTC=$3,216.43
XRP
1 XRP=$0.2866
ETH
1 ETH=$83.61
XUC
1 XUC=$2.11
EOS
1 EOS=$1.81
BCH
1 BCH=$77.93

News Feed 50

Bitcoinist Neutral - 25% of Pantera Capital ICO Projects May Have to Refund Investors read more.
12/14/2018 / 21:00:13
Cointelegraph Neutral - European Parliament Calls for Increased Blockchain Adoption in Trade read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:58:00
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - SEC Chair ‘Optimistic’ DLT and Crypto Will Drive Investment Opportunities read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:55:37
Cointelegraph Neutral - #Bitcoin, Ripple, Ethereum, Stellar, EOS, Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin, Bitcoin SV, TRON, Cardano: Price Analysis, Dec. 14 read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:05:00
Ccn Neutral - Robinhood Didn’t Consult Regulators on New Checking & Savings Account Products read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:03:47
Cryptoglobe Neutral - Crypto Exchange Binance Expands Its Startup Incubator to New Cities read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:00:46
Newsbtc Neutral - Bakkt and Intercontinental Exchange CEOs Weigh in About Bakkt read more.
12/14/2018 / 20:00:42
Themerkle Neutral - Dogecoin Price Remains at $0.002 as Market Cap top 20 Looms read more.
12/14/2018 / 19:49:38
Ccn Neutral - Bahrain Central Bank Publishes Draft Cryptocurrency Regulations read more.
12/14/2018 / 19:25:21
Cryptoglobe Neutral - Russian Deputy PM Says Crypto Price Downturns Justifies Cautious Regulation read more.
12/14/2018 / 19:00:00
Ethnews.Com Positive - 0x Announces Token Grant Program Within The Snowstorm Of Crypto Winter read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:47:51
Bitcoinmagazine Neutral - Op Ed: Bitcoin Is a Declaration of Our Monetary Independence read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:43:26
Cryptoinsider Neutral - Part 2: Ethereum vs NEO – Which blockchain has better scalability and security? read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:43:14
Cryptopotato Neutral - Confirmed: Bakkt Futures to Launch on January 24, Presents Milestones Ahead read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:41:14
Ccn Neutral - Binance Adds USDC Trading Pairs – Stellar and Ripple Represented read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:40:14
Newsbtc Neutral - Bitcoin Sets Fresh 2018 Low at $3,200, Altcoins Plunge read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:30:15
Cointelegraph Neutral - Brazilian Premier League Soccer Club Launches Crypto 'Fan Tokens' read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:30:00
Coindesk Positive - This Binance-Backed Crypto Startup Wants to Anonymize Everything read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:00:26
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - U.K. Cryptocurrency Exchange Cubits Shuts Down After $33M Scam read more.
12/14/2018 / 18:00:13
Cryptoglobe Neutral - Circle CEO: Cryptographic Tokens Will Represent Every Form of Financial Asset read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:50:55
Coinspeaker Neutral - Russian Data and Mining Centre Redstone to Start Operations in June 2019 read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:42:59
Trustnodes Neutral - Ethereum Reaches 50 Million Unique Addresses read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:41:27
Ccn Neutral - Bitcoin Cash Price Continues to Crater as Fork Aftertaste Lingers read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:37:11
Cryptoglobe Negative - Bitcoin Hits 15-Month Low as Crypto Market Threatens to Drop Below $100 Billion read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:30:41
Coinspeaker Neutral - Blockchain-Based Asset Management Platform Membrana Announces Token Sale Event read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:30:22
Cointelegraph Neutral - Bahrain’s Central Bank Publishes Draft Regulations on Crypto Assets read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:15:00
Coinspeaker Neutral - Decentralized Financial Service Platform WORBLI Launches Token ShareDrop Event read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:14:24
Coinnounce Neutral - Do We Really Want To Tokenize Everything? And Can We? read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:05:48
Cryptoglobe Neutral - US Government Advises Bitcoin Bomb Threat Victims to Ignore Ransom, Inform the FBI read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:00:36
Newsbtc Neutral - CoinShares Exec: China Crypto Plan Could Make Dystopian Future a Reality read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:00:27
Bitcoinist Neutral - To The Moon! Bitcoin Space Travel Gets Closer As Virgin Galactic Takes Flight read more.
12/14/2018 / 17:00:13
Coinnounce Negative - Bitcoin Cash falling to 0? Is BCH worthless? read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:53:37
Ccn Neutral - Newsflash: Bitcoin Price Slinks Below $3,175 for First Time in 2018 read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:37:02
Coindesk Neutral - Ethereum Chat Startup Status Lays Off 25% of Staff read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:20:53
Cryptonewsreview Neutral - Whatever happened to Burger King’s own official cryptocurrency? read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:09:34
Bitcoin.Com Negative - Markets Update: Bears Continue to Drag Cryptocurrency Prices Down read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:00:09
Cryptoglobe Neutral - WallCoin: US Lawmaker Recommends Using Cryptocurrency to Fund Trump's Mexico Border Wall read more.
12/14/2018 / 16:00:00
Newsbtc Neutral - Crypto ICO Price Continues to Fall, Likely Due to Growing Regulatory Pressure read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:45:12
Blokt Neutral - Ripples’ XRP Trades Near Bottom of Range – New 2018 Low Upcoming? read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:39:46
Cryptoglobe Neutral - #Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – December 14 read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:30:00
Cryptoglobe Neutral - #Bitcoin (BTC) Price Analysis – December 14 read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:30:00
Ccn Neutral - Porsche Arranges $170m Loan Using BBVA’s Blockchain Platform read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:23:44
Trustnodes Neutral - Bitcoin Cash Falls Below Ethereum’s Price for the First Time, is This the End For BCH? read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:22:40
Cointelegraph Neutral - US Credit Union Blockchain Consortium Joins R3's Global Ecosystem read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:22:00
Blokt Neutral - Bitcoin [BTC] Breaks Below Key Support Level Creating New 2018 Low read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:14:13
Coindesk Neutral - EU Parliament Calls for Action on Blockchain Adoption in Trade read more.
12/14/2018 / 15:00:59
Coinspeaker Neutral - TransferGo’s Series B Funding Round Acquires $17.6 Million read more.
12/14/2018 / 14:53:31
Blokt Neutral - Ripple’s VP of Product Management Talks About XRP Price, Blockchain, xRapid, and More With PCMag read more.
12/14/2018 / 14:49:22
Cointelegraph Neutral - Major Spanish Bank BBVA Closes €150 Mln Loan With Porsche Holding Using Blockchain read more.
12/14/2018 / 14:35:00
Cryptoglobe Neutral - #EOS Price Analysis – December 14 read more.
12/14/2018 / 14:30:00
Negative
4.4%
Neutral
94.3%
Positive
1.0%
Mixed
0.2%

Latest comments:

4 min
Hey Sam, how is it going? But I must explain to you how all this mistaken idea of denouncing of a pleasure and praising pain was born
3 min
Pretty good. Doing my homework.. No one rejects, dislikes, or avoids pleasure itself, because it is pleasure, but because
2 min
Any chance to go out? To take a trivial example, which of us ever undertakes laborious physical exercise, except to obtain some advantage
2 min
.. Maybe 40-50 mins. I don't know exactly. On the other hand, we denounce with righteous indignation and dislike men who are so beguiled
1 min
Anyway sounds great! These cases are perfectly simple and easy to distinguish.