Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork: How Did We Get Here?

Neutral Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork: How Did We Get Here?

As the actual hard fork of Bitcoin Cash approaches and users face the prospect of two versions of Bitcoin Cash, it's important to remember what led Bitcoin Cash to this situation. As such, here is an albeit incomplete recap.

The Block Size Debate

Beginning around the middle of 2015, Bitcoin blocks started becoming full, and this trend continued for over a year. This meant that the cost of sending a transaction in a reasonable amount of time would necessarily increase. Several developers proposed solutions. There is the obvious solution of simply increasing the size of blocks, but other developers viewed that as not a solution at all, as, they argue, it would make the blockchain bloated and thereby less efficient. Another solution is sidechains, which is the direction that Lightning Network and similar products come from. There is the combination of both, which is what Bitcoin is likely to experience eventually.

The debates surrounding block size were fierce, with two camps emerging and many users caught in between. One camp very clearly supported maintaining the 1MB block size and the other advocated increases. Gavin Andresen forked Bitcoin Classic in February 2016 in an attempt to increase the blocksize. Developer Mike Hearn eventually became frustrated and left Bitcoin development, selling all his coins on the way out.

There was a clear divide between Bitcoin businessmen, Bitcoin developers, and Bitcoin miners as regards what should be done with the network. Bitcoin Classic and other early attempts at forking the chain and increasing block size essentially failed, and beginning near the end of 2016, discussion of a serious effort at hardforking came about, culminating in a Chinese Bitcoin conference where Bitcoin ABC was established.

Enter Craig Wright

From the time of his going public with the claim that he was the man known as Satoshi Nakamoto, Craig Wright became very active in the discussion about blocksize increases. Proponents of increased block size were happy to embrace him as a new supporter with a large media platform to speak from. He quickly became friends with the likes of Roger Ver and Calvin Ayre, two of the most influential proponents of bigger blocks.

Enter BIP91

No block size increase was ever agreed upon within Bitcoin development and Bitmain co-founder Jihan Wu and his company outlined a back-up plan to fork Bitcoin if BIP91, Segregated Witness, was to be activated without a block size increase. Roger Ver and several other businessmen were vocally supportive of the fork, and in August, Bitcoin Cash went live. It quickly became apparent that the mining majority were going to stick with the old Bitcoin Core chain, but gradually, over time, Bitcoin Cash developed its own mining community. Bitcoin Cash initially saw trading highs and then a steep decline in value, eventually recovering.

Just over a year after its foundation as a separate blockchain, several things had changed in Bitcoin Cash. For one, their addressing structure was significantly differentiated from Bitcoin. The block size increase to 8MB, and a subsequent increase to 32MB had gone off without a hitch. Things seemed to be working out for the community.

Bitcoin Cash SV and Bitcoin Cash ABC

Bitcoin ABC was created at a Chinese Bitcoin conference in June 2017. It will be continuing after the fork with a different set of changes from the Bitcoin Cash SV fork, whose first change is to implement a 128MB maximum block size.

SV has the support of Coingeek, the largest Bitcoin Cash mining pool, as well as another large pool and billionaire Calvin Ayre. Bitcoin ABC retains the support of its backers at Bitmain along with Roger Ver and several exchanges. The primary disagreement between the two chains has to do with what Bitcoin ABC views as improvements to the protocol in order to ease the transition to smart contracts. Bitcoin SV's first offering does not include any of these "improvements," introduces four new opcodes, and increases the maximum block size, as noted.

Where We Are Today

Today is November 15 th, a day of regularly scheduled upgrades for Bitcoin Cash, but today will be different from previous hardfork days. All signs point to two Bitcoin Cash versions coming out of today's activity, potentially three. Bitcoin ABC has the majority of the nodes while Bitcoin SV has the majority of the mining. Bitcoin.com has announced that it will be pushing all its mining efforts, nearly 1,000 PH/s, toward the Bitcoin ABC side of the fork.

The future of both coins is very uncertain. Separately, on exchanges where they have been pre-listed, they had roughly split the market capitalization of Bitcoin Cash, neither one rising above $300. The Bitcoin Cash originally token did not go much below $400 at any point, but now users will be credited with ABC and SV tokens on most exchanges.

What The Future Holds

It's easy to forecast when things are this uncertain - plenty of people will predict the success or failure of either chain - and it's easy to be wrong in such predictions. The sway of the economic majority is strong, so it is likely that the Bitcoin ABC token will see more active trading and acceptance than the SV token.

But the crypto community is very forgiving, so it can also be expected that with time both tokens will be embraced as equally important, one having much larger blocks and reportedly stripping away changes that Bitcoin Core made to the code over the years, including P2SH, as Craig Wright described in a recent interview. Bitcoin ABC will continue to focus on improving speed of transactions and has long floated the notion of introducing efficient smart contracts.

Featured image from Shutterstock.

Follow us on Telegram or subscribe to our newsletter here.
Who is Buying Bitcoin? Take the survey here and help us with our study.

11/15/2018 / 16:59:55 Source: ccn

BTC
1 BTC=$3,489.26
XRP
1 XRP=$0.3085
ETH
1 ETH=$91.02
XUC
1 XUC=$2.07
EOS
1 EOS=$2.02
BCH
1 BCH=$98.52

News Feed 50

Newsbtc Neutral - Bitcoin Climbs to $3,500, Analyst Claims There is Nothing Unique About the Crypto Bubble read more.
12/12/2018 / 20:00:46
Cryptoglobe Neutral - KFC In Venezuela Not Using DASH, Contrary To Media Reports read more.
12/12/2018 / 20:00:00
Cointelegraph Neutral - #Bitcoin, Ripple, Ethereum, Stellar, EOS, Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin SV, Litecoin, TRON, Cardano: Price Analysis, Dec. 12 read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:35:00
Ccn Neutral - Romania: Bitcoin Exchange CEO Vlad Nistor Arrested for Money Laundering, May Face US Extradition read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:33:59
Bitcoinmagazine Neutral - Bitwala Is Offering German Citizens Joint Crypto and Fiat Banking Accounts read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:32:55
Themerkle Neutral - What Is the Darknet? read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:26:49
Cryptopotato Neutral - #Ethereum Price Analysis Dec.12: Where Do You Go, Ether? read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:15:59
Bitcoinmagazine Neutral - This New Lightning Wallet Allows You to Receive Tips Without Running a Node read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:09:26
Ethnews.Com Negative - IBM Hopes To Strengthen 'Do Not Call' Registries With Blockchain read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:01:22
Cryptoglobe Neutral - Cryptocurrencies Should Be 'Outlawed’, Allianz GI CEO Claims read more.
12/12/2018 / 19:00:02
Bitcoinmagazine Neutral - The World’s First ERC-20 and Bitcoin Atomic Swap Has Taken Place read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:50:19
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - BCH Devs Discuss Securing Instant Transactions With the Avalanche Protocol read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:45:59
Ccn Neutral - ‘What is Bitcoin’ Ranked Among Top Google Searches in 2018 read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:32:05
Cryptopotato Neutral - What’s The Real Reason Behind Coinbase Not Listing Ripple XRP? read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:24:32
Cointelegraph Neutral - Russian Deputy Prime Minister: Draft Crypto Legislation Won’t Be ‘Significantly’ Edited read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:20:00
Bitcoinmagazine Neutral - Prosecutors Seek 10-Year Jail Sentence for Karpeles Over Mt. Gox Embezzling read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:15:29
Cointelegraph Neutral - Dutch Central Bank Proposes License Requirement for Cryptocurrency Service Providers read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:14:00
Cointelegraph Neutral - Russian Draft Bill Blocking Suspicious Financial Websites ‘Could’ Cover ‘Scam’ ICOs, Experts Note read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:05:00
Cryptoglobe Neutral - UAE, Saudi Arabia to Jointly Launch Cryptocurrency for Interbank Transactions read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:00:51
Bitcoinist Neutral - Coinbase Slammed For Venezuela ZCash Airdrop Being an ‘Advertising Strategy’ read more.
12/12/2018 / 18:00:25
Trustnodes Neutral - Southern Europe Signs Blockchain Accord, House Bill to Promote Cryptos, CFTC Requests Comments on ETH, Augur Faces a Governance Question read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:59:57
Blokt Neutral - XYO Will Launch the Blockchain Satellite ‘EtherX’ into Space Using a SpaceX Falcon 9 read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:59:36
Cointelegraph Neutral - IBM Research Teams up With Agritech Firm to Boost African Agribusiness with Blockchain read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:51:00
Blokt Neutral - Galaxy Digital’s Mike Novogratz Narrates His Crypto Journey, Says He Is Still Bullish read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:34:31
Newsbtc Neutral - Crypto Exchange OKEx Relists Bitcoin ABC Under Original Bitcoin Cash (BCH) Ticker read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:30:31
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - Bitwala Begins Offering Bank Accounts With Bitcoin Wallet and Debit Card read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:15:05
Ccn Neutral - Bitcoin Price ‘Could Go from Bad to Worse’: Bearish Analyst read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:11:23
Coindesk Neutral - Ethereum’s Geth Software Upgrades Ahead of January Hard Fork read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:00:47
Cryptoinsider Neutral - Dogecoin is more decentralized than NEO, IOTA, NEM, Stellar, and Nano read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:00:23
Cryptoglobe Neutral - UK-Based Exchange CEX.IO Moving To Mandatory User Registration read more.
12/12/2018 / 17:00:00
Newsbtc Neutral - Only 4 Crypto Exchanges Have 100,000+ Active Users read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:59:30
Trustnodes Neutral - Most Cryptos Very Close to the Bottom Says This Week’s Technical Analysis read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:29:15
Coinspeaker Neutral - Electronics Giant Samsung is Allegedly Planning to Launch ‘Blockchain Smartphone’ read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:27:03
Cointelegraph Neutral - Canadian City of Calgary Launches Local Digital Currency for Intracity Transactions read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:21:00
Blokt Neutral - EOS Breaks Downward Trend as Market Leader Bitcoin [BTC] Finds Support read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:14:13
Cointelegraph Neutral - Germany’s Second Largest Stock Exchange, SolarisBank Partner to Launch Crypto Exchange read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:12:00
Blokt Neutral - IBM May Offer Blockchain-based Solutions to Indian Telcos read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:09:41
Cointelegraph Neutral - Allianz Global Investors CEO Says Crypto Assets Should Be ‘Outlawed’ read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:07:00
Ccn Neutral - Razer Wants Gamers to Mine Cryptocurrency Using their Idle GPUs — But You Probably Shouldn’t read more.
12/12/2018 / 16:01:42
Blokt Neutral - Full-Blown Reversal for the Price of Factom [FCT] read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:59:59
Trustnodes Neutral - Bitcoin Tops “What is…” Google Searches in US and UK read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:51:01
Cointelegraph Neutral - China: Shenzhen Special Economic Zone to Use Blockchain for Electronic Tax Invoices read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:50:00
Blokt Neutral - Ripple’s XRP Continues Range Trading As Market Leader Bitcoin [BTC] Finds Support read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:48:21
Ccn Neutral - What is Holding Coinbase Back From Integrating Ripple (XRP) Into its Exchange? read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:35:52
Cryptoglobe Negative - #Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – December 12 read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:28:49
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - Netherlands to Regulate Cryptocurrencies in Bid to Curb Money Laundering read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:15:35
Blokt Neutral - Bitcoin [BTC] Tests Key Support Level – Bullish or Bearish? read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:14:47
Newsbtc Negative - Billionaire Mike Novogratz Says Crypto ICO Market is Pretty Much Dead Now read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:09:15
Cointelegraph Neutral - India’s Telecom Regulator Completes Mobile Blockchain Pilot with IBM read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:09:00
Cointelegraph Neutral - Crypto Exchange Coincheck’s Owner Monex to Launch Crypto Trading in US starting Q1 2019 read more.
12/12/2018 / 15:04:00
Negative
4.5%
Neutral
94.4%
Positive
0.9%
Mixed
0.2%

Latest comments:

4 min
Hey Sam, how is it going? But I must explain to you how all this mistaken idea of denouncing of a pleasure and praising pain was born
3 min
Pretty good. Doing my homework.. No one rejects, dislikes, or avoids pleasure itself, because it is pleasure, but because
2 min
Any chance to go out? To take a trivial example, which of us ever undertakes laborious physical exercise, except to obtain some advantage
2 min
.. Maybe 40-50 mins. I don't know exactly. On the other hand, we denounce with righteous indignation and dislike men who are so beguiled
1 min
Anyway sounds great! These cases are perfectly simple and easy to distinguish.