Op-Ed: Will Crypto Miners Abandon Craig Wright’s Bitcoin Cash Fork?

Neutral Op-Ed: Will Crypto Miners Abandon Craig Wright’s Bitcoin Cash Fork?

BitMEX's head of research, Jonathan Bier, gave a statement to Bloomberg this week that will soon be proven true or false. In regards to how the upcoming Bitcoin Cash fork would play out, Bier said that he believes that the important divide between the economic majority and the mining majority will sort itself out in rapid fashion.

"The chain will split in two, but the economy will support ABC and reject SV (Satoshi's Vision). SV will have a low price and miners will leave it in a few weeks. That is my prediction."

As head of research, Bier would have played an important role in the roll-out of the new fork monitoring tool that Bitmex has sponsored.

A Theory with Legs

Bier's prediction is based on the reality of the situation rather than personal feelings regarding the technicalities of the upcoming hard fork. It is an informed and wizened view. The economic majority in a cryptocurrency is, in real terms, as important as the mining majority. There are a lot of reasons for this, not the least of which is the cost of the hardware involved in mining cryptocurrencies.

Miners take financial risks on hardware with the reasonable expectation that they will be able to earn a return. If one or the other chain is better equipped to service that result, then that will become the preferred chain of miners, and if they are within a few dozen dollars of each other in unit price, this preference can fluctuate algorithmically in ways that can have a dramatically negative effect on everyday users as difficulties rise and fall and make block times irregular.

Demonstration of this principle is not hard to find. There are many orders of magnitude more miners, pools, mining pools, and so forth contributing to the difficulty of the Bitcoin network than Bitcoin Cash 's current network as a whole. Yet, Bitcoin Cash itself (owing in large part to its architecture being almost identical to that of Bitcoin's, with some important differences) likely has as much of a lead on the majority of other altcoins.

Some exchanges have decided in advance that they will not list Bitcoin SV at all, but they are just a few of hundreds of places that people transact in BCH. Multiple major exchanges have already made pairs including both versions of Bitcoin Cash, enabling traders to engage in pre-fork futures trading.

Other Possibilities

While Bier's informed opinion on the matter represents one likely outcome - that Bitcoin SV loses both economic and mining support in that order and in a short span of time - there are others.

As noted in the Bloomberg article, Calvin Ayre and other wealthy individuals - some of whom, like Ayre, own a lot of cryptos as well as mining hardware - have skin in this game. They could conceivably, by themselves and at a loss (although not in their rational self-interest), prop the SV price up for a time.

The likelihood that Ayre's planned appeals to Bitcoin exchanges - to only list his version of Bitcoin Cash - are successful feels, well, very small. Purely to stimulate trading of the SV coin (or any trading at all) on their exchange(s) and encourage deposits, some exchanges might well list SV exclusively. It would alienate some users, but the 80/20 rule applies: 20 percent of customers make up 80 percent of many business models. In this case, some small exchanges might want that 20 percent to become SV diehards or just people looking to dump their SV coins, or some combination of both. But anything approaching a volume or economic majority? Forget about it.

A scenario that feels likely to this reporter is that both chains live on indefinitely. Whether or not either token enjoys a bullish token price across exchanges, it's hard to imagine Craig Wright or Calvin Ayre coming back into the fold at this point, nor Roger Ver and Jihan Wu welcoming them back if they decided to do so. CoinGeek by itself has the capability to prop up the SV blockchain, and its media efforts have the capability to continually attract new users and widen the base. (Bitcoin ABC has the same capabilities utilizing a wider array of resources - Jihan Wu, Roger Ver, the coterie of major exchanges which have come out in definitive support of ABC.)

Ayre, Wright, and their sizable number of supporters seem to share a very specific vision for cryptocurrency, and it seems that only complete capitulation of their peers would be enough for them to call it quits this far in. A whole generation of Bitcoin mining hardware is soon to be obsolete with next-generation miners coming online, and this soon-to-be-resold hardware has a convenient retirement plan: mine on one or all of the latter-day Bitcoin blockchains. Effectively, a dedication or rededication of any significant amount of hash power from unexpected sources to either chain would change outcomes significantly, and this possibility relies very much, of course, on the market performance of either.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in the article are solely those of the author and do not represent those of, nor should they be attributed to, CCN. Featured Image from nChain/YouTube

Follow us on Telegram or subscribe to our newsletter here.
Who is Buying Bitcoin? Take the survey here and help us with our study.

11/14/2018 / 23:25:12 Source: ccn

BTC
1 BTC=$3,669.24
XRP
1 XRP=$0.3451
ETH
1 ETH=$100.13
XUC
1 XUC=$2.24
EOS
1 EOS=$2.69
BCH
1 BCH=$105.04

News Feed 50

Cointelegraph Neutral - JPMorgan Chase Analysts Say Prolonged Crypto Bear Market Is Scaring Off Institutions read more.
12/18/2018 / 23:15:00
Themerkle Neutral - Darknet Vendors Charge $1 per Stolen Personal Data “Account” read more.
12/18/2018 / 23:07:56
Cointelegraph Neutral - Bitcoin Payment Processor Closes Seed Investment Round Backed by Tim Draper read more.
12/18/2018 / 22:40:00
Coindesk Neutral - Blythe Masters, CEO of Blockchain Startup Digital Asset, Is Stepping Down read more.
12/18/2018 / 22:31:14
Ccn Neutral - Wanchain 3.0 Adds Loopring Enabling On-Chain Decentralized Trading read more.
12/18/2018 / 22:19:57
Bitcoinist Neutral - Binance CEO Says ‘It Doesn’t Have to Be a Competition’ With Coinbase read more.
12/18/2018 / 22:00:09
Cointelegraph Neutral - Gaming Giant Atari to Launch ‘Blockchain Versions’ of Two Popular Games read more.
12/18/2018 / 22:00:00
Coinspeaker Neutral - Maltese Blockchain Bank Set to Start Operations by Mid-2019 read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:59:43
Cointelegraph Neutral - Russian Region Conducts Blockchain Election With 40K Participants read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:45:00
Newsbtc Neutral - Bitcoin Is Here to Stay: Blockstream Satellite Expansion Makes Sure of It read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:30:37
Cointelegraph Neutral - Pro-Bitcoin Official in the White House: What We Know About Trump’s New Chief Of Staff read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:20:00
Ccn Neutral - Binance Labs Launches 8 Blockchain Startups read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:16:31
Newsbtc Neutral - Novogratz: Interest Left Crypto for Macro, But Bitcoin Will Emerge As Store of Value read more.
12/18/2018 / 21:02:27
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - Cointext Rolls Out Mobile BCH Services in Bangladesh, Now Services 38 Countries read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:55:03
Cointelegraph Neutral - Korean Gov’t Pilots Blockchain for Logistics Innovation in Country’s Largest Port read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:54:00
Cryptoinsider Neutral - VeChain: Supply chain management protocol for counterfeit prevention read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:43:28
Coindesk Neutral - Overstock’s Medici Acquires Digital Tokens Representing Startup Equity Shares read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:41:31
Ccn Neutral - Bull Gone: Bitcoin Price Forming Doji to Signal Potential Trend Reversal read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:21:38
Themerkle Positive - Bitcoin Cash Price Rises to $100 And Overtakes Litecoin read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:00:51
Newsbtc Neutral - Bitcoin Sustains Above $3,500 After Widespread Market Rally read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:00:36
Coindesk Neutral - Tim Draper Invests $1.25 Million in Bitcoin Payments Processor OpenNode read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:00:06
Cryptoglobe Neutral - The Week: Stablecoin Basis Folds, Revolut Wins Banking License, Swiss Crypto Exchange Launching read more.
12/18/2018 / 20:00:00
Ccn Neutral - Stablecoin Company Tether Ltd. Made $6.6 Million in Interest from January to July 2018, Report Does Not Confirm Full Cash Reserves read more.
12/18/2018 / 19:23:04
Ethnews.Com Neutral - German Bank Tests Blockchain For Development In Africa read more.
12/18/2018 / 19:09:38
Themerkle Neutral - First Major Christmas 2018 Crypto Scam Targets Basic Attention Token read more.
12/18/2018 / 19:02:37
Bitcoinist Neutral - Blockstream Satellite Now Means Most Of The World Can Use Bitcoin Without Internet read more.
12/18/2018 / 19:00:09
Cryptoglobe Neutral - Iran Minister Indicates Support for Blockchain, Both Public and Private Uses read more.
12/18/2018 / 19:00:00
Ccn Neutral - Atari Partners With Startup to Make Blockchain Versions of Popular Titles like Roller Coaster Tycoon read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:56:55
Cointelegraph Neutral - Israel: Financial Services Firm GMT Joins RippleNet read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:52:00
Cryptopotato Neutral - EOS Block Producers Are in Risk of Bankruptcy Despite The Recent 25% Price Gain read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:34:32
Newsbtc Negative - Bitcoin Scam Alert: Criminals Demand BTC Payment to Call Off Hit Man read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:30:39
Ccn Neutral - Education The Biggest Barrier Preventing Online Investors From Purchasing Cryptocurrency read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:23:47
Cointelegraph Neutral - Belgium's Financial Watchdog Updates Crypto Scam Blacklist to Total 113 Sites read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:22:00
Cryptoglobe Neutral - BitMEX Trading Volume Way Down After Supports Broken read more.
12/18/2018 / 18:00:00
Coinspeaker Neutral - 550,000+ Hotels in 210 Countries Can Now be Booked with XRP read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:59:51
Cointelegraph Neutral - A Year After $20K, Blockchain Capital Exec Says Investors Will Regret Not Buying in Now read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:59:00
Themerkle Neutral - Institutional Investors No Longer Interested in Bitcoin: JP Morgan read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:41:35
Blokt Neutral - Japan’s New Crypto Regulation Draft Report Is Ready read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:29:23
Trustnodes Neutral - ICOs Now Trading on Exchanges With Investors’ ETH read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:28:21
Coinnounce Neutral - Bitcoin institutional adoption rising: BTC price analysis read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:24:41
Newsbtc Neutral - Electricity Consumption of Bitcoin is a Non-Issue: Solar Energy is Free in Some Regions read more.
12/18/2018 / 17:01:42
Blokt Neutral - NewEconoLab’s NeoRay Will Make NEO Smart Contract Development Easier read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:59:35
Financemagnates Neutral - eToro Survey Finds Huge Demand for Cryptocurrency Education read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:59:02
Bitcoin.Com Neutral - Transnistria Welcomes Crypto Miners, Plans to Expand the Industry read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:55:50
Ccn Neutral - Bitcoin Bear Market Is Scaring Off Institutional Investors, Claims JPMorgan read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:54:56
Coinspeaker Neutral - Basis Shutting Down Due to Regulatory Pressure read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:54:31
Ethnews.Com Neutral - Daily Byte: Tuesday, December 18, 2018 read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:43:07
Blokt Neutral - AlterVerse Will Adopt Enjin Blockchain for All of Its 17 Gaming Worlds read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:29:35
Cryptopotato Neutral - Crypto Market Update Dec.18: One Year Passed Since Bitcoin’s ATH. Following The Correction, What’s Next? read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:29:15
Cryptoinsider Neutral - ‘Proof of Keys’ is coming, but what is it? read more.
12/18/2018 / 16:26:28
Negative
4.1%
Neutral
94.5%
Positive
1.1%
Mixed
0.2%

Latest comments:

4 min
Hey Sam, how is it going? But I must explain to you how all this mistaken idea of denouncing of a pleasure and praising pain was born
3 min
Pretty good. Doing my homework.. No one rejects, dislikes, or avoids pleasure itself, because it is pleasure, but because
2 min
Any chance to go out? To take a trivial example, which of us ever undertakes laborious physical exercise, except to obtain some advantage
2 min
.. Maybe 40-50 mins. I don't know exactly. On the other hand, we denounce with righteous indignation and dislike men who are so beguiled
1 min
Anyway sounds great! These cases are perfectly simple and easy to distinguish.